Slides showing evolution of “How are you feeling” (French).
My “how are you feeling” chart using inclusive language in French, Spanish, and many more languages. Contact me if you want to create this poster in the language you teach.
Rejoinders/Reactions students can use to react to their classmates sharing their feelings (French).
SEE IT IN ACTION
After 15 lessons with complete beginners
BACKGROUND STORY (2014)
At the Agen workshop last summer, Lynette Saint George always started her lessons by asking students how they felt, she would circulate an iPad with a slide full of faces expressing different emotions. At the time, I thought it was a very neat way of starting class. I have since then discovered it is a wonderful path to language acquisition.
I started the experiment with my very small High School French 1 class. Every day since the beginning of the year, we have been gathering around the smartboard and I have been asking each of them “Comment tu te sens?”. At first, students would simply point at the face and word that best represented their feeling. I started with three faces: exhausted, happy, and frustrated (I figured most teenagers experience one or more of these feelings every day of the week). I then started providing Comprehensible Input and options for answers such as “you feel frustrated because there is an exam?” (“there is” is a phrase I teach early on + “exam” is a cognate). Of course, I am the one doing most of the talking but since it is about something they greatly care about, they are engaged.
Slowly, I increased the amount of faces on the slide and taught them a few easy rejoinders so that they could react to how others were feeling: “Poor Kelsey”, “Good luck”, “That’s life”, and “Hooray”. They also started asking for useful words/phrases, which I happily gave them such as “my _____ hurts”.
Our daily “How ARE YOU FEELING?” routine
We are now in the second quarter of their first year in French and my students are saying things like “I feel exhausted because I did not sleep well” or “I feel happy because there is a new One Direction song” or “I feel ecstatic because I have rowing practice”. I am now moving on to “talking” about our week-end on Monday (in the past) and on Friday (in the near future), feeling SO thankful for the “Shelter vocabulary, not grammar” TPRS advice! Finally, I have started shifting the responsibility of questioning to the students, we take turn asking the “how do you feel” question and “why”; sometimes students will ask an additional question (like when Erika said she felt happy because she was going to the movies, everyone wanted to know “Avec qui????”). Sometimes, our “How are you feeling” routine takes 5 minutes, sometimes it takes 20 min. I usually just follow the students’ lead and energy.
One day, I was in a rush to get to an assessment and skipped “how do you feel?”, the students called me on it “are we not doing our therapy circle today?”. I thought I was going to cry: they don’t see it at language or classwork, they see it as therapy! This reminds me of Stephen Krashen‘s blog post, “The End of Motivation”. Krashen says: “Here is the crucial part: Jack’s Mandarin was improving, but he was not aware of it. He was only interested in the stories.” I guess I could probably say “My students’ French was improving, but they were not aware of it. They were only interested in whom Erika was going to the movies with.”
Now, I realize I am lucky to have a class of 7 students. With a much bigger class, the pace is so much slower. I cannot gather my 27 7th graders around the board, nor can I ask each and everyone one of them how they feel every day. By now, all of them can pretty much ask and say how they feel but very few can elaborate beyond “I am happy because it’s Friday”. And that’s totally OK, I just follow their pace and keep providing as much comprehensible input as possible. If anyone is successfully using a personal guiding question such as “How are you feeling?” with a big class and would like to share, I would really love it!
The other day, I wrote on the board some of the answers my students used to respond to “how do you feel?” (in blue at the top). Below their sentences is the input I provided in this particular session (in blue and black).
[…] I was nerding out to all of my favorite language blogs, I stumbled upon Cecile Laine’s great post about starting class by asking students how they feel and providing possible responses. […]
[…] Well, these two anecdotes tells me most of them do: 1) we talk about how we feel everyday (our daily warm-up). Two or three weeks, Ben attempted to use the past tense, he stumbled and self corrected a few […]
[…] After viewing and quickly debriefing a very short video explaining how students will understand me if I only speak French, I jumped right into my favorite activity of the day, the warm-up we will run every single day even if we only have 15 min of class due to snow delay, the warm-up that earned me the feed-back of “you should be a counselor, you know us so well” by my 7th graders, the warm-up that was one of my biggest aha moments at my first TPRS conference in Agen, 2014: How do you feel? […]
I love this! Thanks for sharing. Here is a great resource page for Spanish teachers: https://espanolparainmigrantes.wordpress.com/2014/06/07/como-estas-estados-de-animo/
This is a great idea! I often open class by asking “How are you?” but I just get boring answers–“good,” “fine,” etc. But this is a great idea to give them options with the different emotions! Thank you for sharing!!!
Thanks so much for the PPT!
Thanks for sharing this…I’ve started to use it and today a “natural” extension was discovered. I start my classes with day, date, and weather after “comment tu te sens” and today I was able to tell students “Je me sens triste parce que l’été termine samedi.” This led to students saying they were happy because “l’automne arrive dimanche” . It made a nice opportunity to circle days of the week, seasons, and weather.
[…] Laine 0 Comments Something really interesting happened today : we have been doing my “how are you feeling routine” for roughly 2 months now with my Novice students and this week I sensed a bit of a fatigue […]
[…] How are you feeling today? […]
With my larger classes, I have students ask each other the questions in partners or small groups so they all get to express themselves at least to a peer. 🙂 Thanks for the wonderful slide show!
Yes absolutely, that is the end goal! 🙂
[…] Well, these two anecdotes tell me some of them do: 1) we talk about how we feel everyday (our daily warm-up). Two or three weeks ago, Ben attempted to use the past tense, he stumbled and self corrected a few […]