Crowdsourcing at ACTFL: How do we develop empathy?

On a chilly Sunday morning at 8 a.m., in a city bustling with marathon runners, I presented on Cultivating Cultural Connections: A Novice Approach. Honestly, I expected only a handful of attendees. I was thrilled to see a sizable crowd show up—and also immediately regretted having prepared a post-it share out instead of a padlet or a google doc 🙂

I set out to address some of the challenges faced by World Language teachers in developing the intercultural competence of their Novice learners. First, investigating cultural products, practices and perspectives with students who have limited language skills, poses a unique challenge. Second, in a post-George Floyd world, fostering students’ understanding of diverse target language cultures requires a prior appreciation of cultures and identities within their classrooms and local communities.

How do we develop empathy?

During the session, I asked participants to share something they do to center their students’ cultures and to develop empathy toward each other. As stated above, this seems to be a pre-requisite before investigating cultures they may or may not be familiar with. Here is my working definition of “Culture”:

Participants’ insights

Here are the insights shared by participants during the session. The number in parenthesis indicates how many participants said the same thing or something very similar. All these suggestions are gems and wherever possible, I have linked the idea to a resource for you to investigate:

  • “Incorporate important events in their lives in Calendar Talk” (5)
  • “Personalized Questions & Answers (PQA)” (5)
  • “Surveys” (3)
  • “Ask students to find 5 things they have in common with their peers, including common concerns” (2)
  • “Use students as the topic of study” (2)
  • “If the topic is food, start with what they usually eat in their homes” (2)
  • “Find out which celebrities they know and like and use them in your curriculum” (Example)
  • “Set norms
  • “Model empathy and respectful curiosity”
  • “Who is in the class? Students share a slide with pictures about themselves that showcases what they want us to know”
  • ” After reading a short story in L2, I ask them to present a story from their own culture”
  • Weekend chat
  • “Chatmat from Amy Lenord (Anchors and Aides) on “My Identity” leads to an All About Me poster” [Note: this resource is available in several languages]
  • “Gratitude Journals”
  • “Celebrate holidays and birthdays”
  • “When students are writing about where they live, I provide vocabulary unique to our town/state”
  • “Teaching the word because unlocks beliefs + values”
  • “Help them make connections between L2 and their home language (Arabic, Portuguese, etc.). Let them showcase their home language”
  • “Use songs with multiple languages (not just L2)” (Example)
  • “I remind them to embraces differences”

Your turn!

Do you have more ideas for centering students’ cultures and fostering empathy? I’d love to hear them—comment below!

PS: If you were in my session and do not see your idea, my apologies. I might not have been able to read your handwriting or did not understand how your idea supports centering our students’ cultures first. Please comment below to expand on your idea, I would love to include it.

Below are some further nuggets from my session, captured by my colleague Dorie Conlon. if you want to know more, head to Claudia Elliott’s podcast where we discuss intercultural competence for Novice learners.

14 responses to “Crowdsourcing at ACTFL: How do we develop empathy?”

  1. marishawkins Avatar

    It was truly a pleasure to learn from you at ACTFL! Your idea that we need to be centering people as a HUGE part of the 3 ps is so spot on, and I don’t know why ACTFL hasn’t considered that. Without it, the other 3 p’s seem so disconnected and impersonal. Also, I really loved how you included how people in your own community celebrate Diwali. Throughout the presentation, you also modeled how your own thinking and practice has evolved which is so valuable! I think it can seem like as presenters, people just always taught this way- which isn’t true! One of my favorite take aways was how you incorporate Picture Talk with multiple choice questions. I am so glad that I fought through the marathon to make it to most of your presentation!

    1. Cécile Lainé Avatar

      What a pleasure to finally meet you face to face at ACTFL. Thank you for braving the marathon and for your kind feedback! If your idea is not already on a post-it note (or if I did not do it justice), please share here.

  2. AnneMarie Chase Avatar

    Oh Cécile! This is so important for us to consider and thank you for sharing it beyond ACTFL! I saw Dorie’s post about the 4th P- People and I was like 🤯! Yes! That’s what this is all about!! Thank you, thank you and I hope I get to learn from you in person soon! ❤️AnneMarie

    1. Cécile Lainé Avatar

      Merci, Anne Marie! Please do contribute ideas to this post. You are the queen of humanizing kids in your classroom. I look forward to working with you this summer.

  3. Elodie Channa Avatar
    Elodie Channa

    Merci Cécile for sharing your session highlights for those of us (aka me!) who weren’t at ACTFL.

    Your participants shared some great ideas and I would have answered with very similar answers, but here are a few more little things that I do too:
    – When students do presentational speaking, I finish their presentation by asking the audience (aka the rest of the class) to give compliments or share something they learned
    – Modeling sharing about myself/ being vulnerable. If the expectations is that students need to share these very personal parts of themselves, I find that it goes a long way when the teacher goes first.
    – Welcoming students by name when they walk in
    – Incorporating SEL activities
    – Setting the expectations that laughing at other students is not ok (usually happens in the first few days/weeks when a student makes a “language error”)

    1. Cécile Lainé Avatar

      These are wonderful, merci beaucoup!

  4. Samantha Wilson Avatar
    Samantha Wilson

    I love this post so much! It makes complete sense for “people” to be added to the three Ps, from every level 1-AP. I enjoyed reading the comments from the workshop and even though I try to incorporate many of the activities, I’m inspired to incorporate even more. Bien hecho, amiga! I so wish I could have attended because YOU inspire me!

    1. Cécile Lainé Avatar

      Awww, merci.

  5. […] to reconnect with Dorie Conlon, whose work I really respect and admire, and saw this tweet about a session she attended by Cécile Lainé (another source of […]

  6. Nicole Reed Avatar
    Nicole Reed

    I have enjoyed reading your presentation highlights —thank you for sharing! Empathy is a thought-provoking concept and an essential human value. While reading through your insights and teachers’ practices, I was reminded of our shared responsibility of shaping well-rounded, global citizens.

    One way that I like to foster empathy in my classroom is through collaborative thinking where students are engaged in actively considering a variety of perspectives as they form, and many times, reshape their own in order to create a well-rounded response. For example, in reading comprehension, students can collaboratively think on the messages, main ideas or moral of a specific story—this does not only provide them with a seat at the table (bring their own set of perspectives), but it also creates room for effective communication, active listening, emotional intelligence, it builds trust, mutual respect, and provides an opportunity to broaden their own previous conceptions.

    I also have some food for thought after reading your post… I love art, and I always look to find new ways to include it in my class discussions… I think it would be fascinating to see empathy at work in small discussions while using photography. Much like ‘picture talk’ activities, photography could create space for brainstorming, a variety of interpretations, thoughts, reflection and, ultimately (and hopefully), an environment that fosters understanding and perspective-taking.

    1. Cécile Lainé Avatar

      Thank you for your thoughtful suggestions, Nicole!

  7. […] my recent post on Building Empathy and my 2024 ACTFL session, I had the pleasure of joining Claudia Elliott on her podcast Growing […]

  8. Mariem Avatar
    Mariem

    I am revisiting the ACTFL sessions to organize takeaways under one document. Unfortunately, I missed your session because I was trapped in my car trying to get to my already paid parking garage (which was located in front the convention center 🙁 I am grateful for this post and comments and I agree that without people, there’s no culture to study!

    1. Cécile Lainé Avatar

      Thanks, Mariem. To catch-up on my session head to Claudia Elliott’s podcast episode 132. Here is a link! https://towardproficiency.com/2025/01/30/building-intercultural-competence-in-the-novice-classroom/

Leave a Reply

Discover more from TOWARD PROFICIENCY

Subscribe now to keep reading and get access to the full archive.

Continue reading